PFAS-free grease barriers for paper: starch, dispersion, extrusion

Quick answer: No PFAS-free route wins everywhere. Water-based and starch-type coatings are the ones to watch for dry or greasy foods that need to stay recyclable, while extrusion coatings still lead where a real moisture barrier decides shelf life. UPM, Ingredion and Paramelt’s starch structure is a prototype with a recyclability pass but, so far, no published Kit or Cobb numbers, so treat it as a candidate to request samples of, not a spec to design around.

Why grease barriers are back on the agenda

Fluorinated treatments used to be the easy answer for greaseproof paper. The PPWR entered into force in February 2025 and generally applies from 12 August 2026, which is also when its PFAS limit values for food-contact packaging take effect. That date has now passed, so for anyone selling grease-resistant paper into the EU the question has moved from “what if” to “what’s on the line today”.

The PPWR is EU packaging law and the details (thresholds, scope, guidance) are best read in the source text. See ppwreu.org for the detail, and check the current text before you rely on any summary, including this one.

The practical problem for a materials team is that the barrier has to be replaced without breaking three other things: sealing, printing and end-of-life. A patent review of aqueous coatings notes that most still fall short of LDPE extrusion coating on seal strength, sealing speed, roll blocking resistance, barrier and over-printability. That is an old patent’s view, but it describes the trade-offs buyers still argue about.

What Kit, OGR and Cobb actually measure

Before comparing routes, it helps to know what the headline numbers mean. Three tests do most of the work.

Kit test (TAPPI T559). It uses mixed solvents of castor oil, n-heptane and toluene, numbered from 1 (100 percent castor oil) to 12 (a 45/55 toluene/n-heptane ratio), in order of decreasing viscosity and surface tension. The reported number is the highest solvent that shows no staining after 15 seconds of contact. It was originally developed to judge fluorochemical-treated paper.

OGR (TAPPI T509). Coated paper is exposed to an oil for a set time, and the amount that seeps through onto a blotter is quantified. Higher Kit values are better; lower OGR values are better. That inverted scale catches people out when they compare data sheets from different suppliers.

Cobb (TAPPI T441, ISO 535). It is liquid water absorption in g/m2 over a stated time. A 2025 paper in Packaging Technology and Science ran Cobb1800 to ISO 535:2023 with a 100 cm2 contact area, 100 mL of deionised water and a 30 minute test. A patent example instead used a two-minute exposure. A Cobb figure without its time is close to meaningless.

None of these is a shelf-life test. A TAPPI Journal paper on waterborne coatings argues that new coating technologies need test methods re-evaluated so lab results predict real-world performance. A solvent-based Kit rating tells you about surface energy and film continuity; it doesn’t tell you how a hot, fatty filling behaves after a week in a warehouse. Ask for a food-specific or oil-breakthrough result alongside it.

What the UPM, Ingredion and Paramelt structure shows

UPM announced the collaboration on 20 October 2026, with the three companies investigating how plant-based starch barrier technologies can support recyclable paper food packaging. The build combines UPM Solide Lucent 78 gsm and UPM Asendo 65 gsm papers with Ingredion’s starch-based barrier technology and Paramelt’s bio-based heat-seal and barrier coatings. The co-created structure on Solide Lucent 78 gsm has passed Part 1 recyclability testing at Western Michigan University.

Ingredion’s role is narrow on purpose. Its starch barrier technology is described as showing promising potential for grease resistance. That is a grease barrier claim, not a moisture barrier claim, and the wording is cautious. The samples were shown at PACK EXPO in Chicago, 18 to 21 October.

None of the announcements reviewed for this article published a Kit rating, a coat weight, a Cobb value or a heat-seal range. That’s normal for a trade-show prototype, but it means the real evaluation starts with a sample request. It’s also worth asking what “Part 1” covers and whether later stages are planned, since the releases don’t spell it out.

A related UPM and Paramelt concept came out earlier this year. It pairs UPM Solide Lucent or UPM Prego papers with Paramelt’s Aquavate Bio SB 2383, a water-based coating formulated exclusively from biodegradable components. UPM says it enables low coat weights and reliable performance on existing lines such as VFFS. The components have been individually validated as home compostable. “Individually” is the operative word: a validated coating and a validated paper are not the same as a validated laminated structure.

Comparing the PFAS-free routes

The table below lines up the options reported in the sources used here. Values are typical or claimed figures from the named source, with the test stated in the header or the notes, and none of it is a specification. Blank cells mean no public number was found.

Route Grease result Water or vapour result End-of-life note Best for
Starch grease barrier plus bio heat-seal (UPM, Ingredion, Paramelt) Aimed at grease resistance; no Kit value published Not stated Passed Western Michigan University Part 1 recyclability test (company statement) Dry or greasy food wraps, at pilot stage
Water-based bio coating on barrier base paper (UPM and Paramelt) “Strong grease protection” claimed; no Kit value published Not stated Components individually validated home compostable (company statement) Bakery and grab-and-go on VFFS lines
Aqueous polymer dispersion, supplier benchmark (MC Polymers) Kit 12 or above on flat sheet, TAPPI T559 Cobb 2 g/m2 or below at 10 min, TAPPI T441 Supplier says tested under TAPPI and European recycling protocols Screening benchmark when comparing grades
Extruded LDPE Lower oil and grease resistance than PLA or PBS Much better WVTR than the dispersion coatings and ecovio in a pilot study Patent literature notes repulping difficulty Moist or wet fills where vapour barrier governs
Extruded PLA or PBS Highest OGR in the cited study PBS gave weaker WVTR than Bio-PE (23 C, 50 percent RH) Not stated in the study Oily, dry-ish foods where vapour barrier is secondary

Sources for the rows: MC Polymers lists Cobb at 2 gsm or below per 10 minutes (TAPPI T441) and Kit of 12 or above on the flat sheet (TAPPI T559) as typical benchmarks for its aqueous polymer grades. In the 2025 extrusion study, PLA-based and PBS coatings showed the highest OGR, LDPE was lower because of its higher permeability to oil and grease, and LDPE’s WVTR was significantly lower. Bio-PE gave a superior barrier to water vapour compared with PBS. A coating patent states that PE-extrusion-coated cups and trays have difficulties in repulping and are less easily recyclable than conventional paper or board.

Because the MC Polymers figures are the supplier’s own benchmarks for specific grades, they show what’s achievable on a flat sheet, not what you’ll get after creasing and folding. The 2025 study is useful on that point: certain creased Bio-PE samples unexpectedly showed a higher oxygen barrier than the unconverted material, while the PBS grades behaved more consistently. Convertibility changes the barrier, so request creased-sample data.

How much coating does it take to reach a high Kit level?

Kit rating climbs with coat thickness, and the climb isn’t gentle. A US patent on polysaccharide coatings gives a worked example using TAPPI T559 on a lab drawdown. The control paper failed at kit value 0, while the dextran-coated paper failed at up to kits 3-4, 7-8 or 10-11, depending on the coating thickness. The chart plots the upper end of each reported range.

It’s a dextran example, not a starch one, and a lab drawdown rather than a production line. It’s included because it shows the general shape of the curve for polysaccharide films: a thin coat buys a modest rating, and a high rating takes real coat weight.

Kit level reached by dextran-coated paper at three coat thicknesses (lab example)
Kit level reached by dextran-coated paper at three coat thicknesses (lab example)

That’s the number to chase on a data sheet: the Kit level at a stated coat weight in g/m2 on a stated base paper. A Kit 12 at 12 g/m2 and a Kit 12 at 4 g/m2 are different products for cost, drying energy and repulping yield. Use the unit converter if one supplier quotes gsm and another quotes micrometres, and the material properties table for typical reference values.

Dispersion coating versus extrusion: where the barrier gap is

Grease and moisture are separate problems. Water-based dispersions can do reasonably on grease at low coat weights, but gases and vapour are harder because a thin latex-like film has pinholes until enough layers close them.

A 2022 study in Coatings on waterborne coatings for paperboard puts numbers on it. The OTR of a single-layer coating was very high, 6.2 x 10^4 cm3/(m2 day), and the three-layered coating reached 920 cm3/(m2 day). The double-coated paperboard had a WVTR of 240 g/(m2 day), measured gravimetrically after seven days at 23 C and 85 percent RH. Those are research coatings, not commercial grades, and the OTR is irrelevant for most grease applications. They do show why a dispersion on its own isn’t a moisture barrier for a damp filling.

A pilot-scale study of tandem dispersion and extrusion coating reached a similar conclusion. Pinholes in the dispersion coating samples mattered less for WVTR than for OTR, where values were too high to measure. LDPE’s water vapour barrier was much better than the other materials studied. If you need both grease and vapour barrier, a thin PE layer or a heavier multi-pass coating is the honest comparison, and the recyclability trade-off goes with it. The laminate estimator gives an indicative layer-stack view for that kind of trade-off.

Best for, by use

  • Dry bakery bags and wraps on VFFS: water-based bio or starch-type coatings on a barrier base paper. UPM says its concept with Paramelt is aimed at bakery, fast food and convenience applications, and that it runs at low coat weights. Verify seal range and speed on your own line.
  • Greasy hot food (burgers, fried items): request Kit and oil-breakthrough results at your fill temperature. A Kit rating alone won’t settle it.
  • Moist, chilled or frozen fills: an extrusion layer or a multi-pass coating with a stated WVTR at 38 C and 90 percent RH (ASTM F1249). Dispersion-only results at 23 C and 50 percent RH won’t transfer.
  • Fibre recyclability claims: ask which protocol was used, and for which substrate and coat weight. A “Part 1” pass on one grade doesn’t extend to the whole portfolio.

What this means for you

If you buy paper for food contact. Get the PFAS declaration in writing and ask what test backs it. Then ask for Kit (TAPPI T559), OGR, and Cobb with time stated, all at a named coat weight on a named base paper.

If you run R&D. Put the starch and bio-based dispersion routes on the screening list, but ask UPM, Ingredion and Paramelt for the missing data: Kit rating, coat weight, seal range, Cobb, and what the Western Michigan University Part 1 result covers. Grades vary, and the supplier data sheet decides.

If you own the line. Seal strength and dwell time on your VFFS or flow-wrap machine are the usual failure points for aqueous coatings. Run a trial on your own equipment before approving a switch from PE-coated stock.

If you sign off claims. Keep “recyclable”, “home compostable” and “PFAS-free” as three separate claims with three separate pieces of evidence, and check the current PPWR text at ppwreu.org for the PFAS and recyclability rules. The printable checklists are a handy place to keep that evidence list. Ask your supplier for a quote and a sample before you model any cost in the pack cost calculator.

Sources

Values are typical figures from the cited sources. Grades differ between suppliers. Check the supplier's data sheet and test your own structure before you decide.