Quick answer: A Dutch pilot called BRAVE’R reports an 84% reduction in packaging and a 70% reduction in CO₂ emissions compared with conventional single-use packaging for professional cleaning products. The system pairs durable bottles with a smart bulk-concentrate dispenser. The percentage belongs to one pilot; what carries over to other home care and personal care packs is the closure, the dosing and the data.
This piece rests mainly on statements from Searious Business, which led the pilot, and Ecourage, which sells the refill technology involved. Independent test data was not found, and the full case study was not reviewed for this article.
What BRAVE’R tested
BRAVE’R (Brabant Chooses Reuse) was a Province of Noord-Brabant-funded innovation project led by Searious Business. The partners were technology provider Ecourage, product supplier Vebego Bright Solutions and cleaning operator Vebego Cleaning Services, who tested the system in a live professional setting. Sustainable Packaging News summarised the results on 11 November 2026, and Packaging Europe ran its own report on 18 November 2026.
The same summary says refill can lower costs by over 17%. The pilot also looked at safe handling of cleaning liquids, user adoption, logistics, inventory management and data collection. That list matters more to a packaging engineer than the headline figure, because it describes what breaks first when reuse leaves the slide deck.
One caveat applies to all the percentages: the public summaries don’t say what the baseline pack was or how the reusable bottle’s mass is counted across its reuse cycles. Check the case study at Searious Business before quoting 84% anywhere.
How the system is built
According to Searious Business, the set-up centres on Ecourage’s smart refill dispensers that fill bottles safely, precisely, and hygienically using bulk concentrates. It also lists secure, leak-proof tops that prevent spills and preserve product quality.
The closure is where the engineering sits. A Made case study on Ecourage says each bottle carries an NFC system that links it to a specific brand and a specific product, and that the packaging can only be positioned one way in the machine. Ecourage’s own trade-fair listing describes a smart NFC cap on each reusable package. A beauty trade outlet reports that Ecourage started under its Norwegian parent company, Smartseal Closures, which makes sense: this is a closure business first.
A retail example from Ecourage’s own newsroom shows the same cap on a flexible pack. In a Japanese roll-out, the brand Ecostore’s laundry liquid, fabric softener, wool wash and dish liquid are refilled into the brand’s current 1-litre pouch fitted with Ecourage’s OmniCap. Ecourage states an average of 58 grams of plastic saved per refill (a company claim, with no method given on the page).
Refill formats compared
Refill is a family of formats, not one system. The table lists constructions reported by their makers or by the sources named in the text. The savings are claims on different baselines, so don’t rank them against each other.
| Format | What is reused | What is bought | Reported saving | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bulk concentrate with smart dispenser (BRAVE’R) | Durable bottle with leak-proof top | Bulk concentrate container | 84% packaging (pilot) | Needs dispenser hardware and site logistics |
| Dissolvable pod plus PET bottle (SC Johnson Dissolve) | PET spray bottle | Pod, 0.28 oz of concentrate | Not stated in source | Consumer must add water and fill correctly |
| Sealed cartridge in bottle neck (Lysol Smart Trigger + Refill) | PET bottle, designed for up to 25 reuses | Plastic cartridge, 0.195 oz | Not stated in source | Custom bottle and cartridge fit |
| Flexible refill pouch (case in Recoup study) | 1 L PET bottle, PP flip cap | 2 L PE pouch, PE screw lid | “75% less plastic” (pouch vs pump dispenser) | Opening must match the pouch spout |
| Concentrate pod in measuring cup (Replenish) | Reusable spray bottle | Refill pod | 90% less plastic (Ellen MacArthur Foundation page) | One platform across several products |
Packaging World described the first two systems after SC Johnson introduced Dissolve in February 2022. It reports the pods hold 0.28 oz of cleaner concentrate and go with a reusable, recyclable PET spray bottle. Lysol’s cartridge is inserted, still sealed, into the neck of a custom-designed PET bottle, and the bottle has been designed to be reused up to 25 times.
The pouch row comes from a Recoup refill case-study document (2023), which lists a 1L PET bottle with PP flip cap and a 2L refill pouch made from PE with PE screw on lid. Recoup also flags that introducing refill sachets can require rethinking the dispenser’s mechanism. The Ellen MacArthur Foundation page on Replenish says one pod is the equivalent of six bottles, cutting plastic packaging by 90%.
Where the saving comes from
Most of the reduction comes from shipping less water in less plastic. The same Ellen MacArthur Foundation page notes that a typical bottle of cleaner is 90% water and less than 10% actual valuable ingredients. Move the dilution to the point of use, or fill a durable bottle from bulk, and the single-use pack shrinks to a concentrate container.
The Lysol figures show the scale. The refill cartridge holds 0.195 oz of concentrate and, when added to water in the reusable bottle, produces 25 oz of cleaner.
Our calculation: 25 ÷ 0.195 ≈ 128, so the finished product is about 128 times the volume of the cartridge contents. If the source means US fluid ounces (it only says “oz”), that is roughly 5.8 mL of concentrate (0.195 × 29.57) making about 739 mL of cleaner (25 × 29.57). The cartridge, though, is still a pack, and its mass per dose is what a packaging team would compare against a trigger bottle.
Closures and dosing decide whether it survives use
Professional users have a long record of bypassing dosing hardware. A European Cleaning Journal piece, from an older issue, quotes a supplier saying that companies install dosing systems but after a few weeks, cleaners go back to free-pouring the product into a bucket. The BRAVE’R promoters list the same problem from the other side: correct, consistent dosing independent of the user, and refill-time recording that makes reuse cycles countable. That list comes from a Searious Business LinkedIn post, which is a promotional source.
Material choice is the other constraint. In a Design News article from 2023, a supplier voice explains that cleaning products often contain chemicals that can degrade packaging over time, and are typically kept for much longer by the consumer than foods. A bottle meant for dozens of refills has to survive both the formulation and the shelf time, so stress-crack and chemical-resistance data for your own formula matter more than a generic resin data sheet.
The regulatory backdrop
The EU’s Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) sets reuse and refill obligations that affect this category; check the current text and the detail at ppwreu.org. Packaging Europe reported that Commissioner Jessika Roswall stated existing reusable packaging will not need to be redesigned to comply with new label rules, in its article on the prototype ecodesign label. Searious Business also pitches the data trail as a way to support PPWR, DPP and UPV reporting, which is a claim from the project’s own page.
What this means for you
- R&D and packaging engineering: treat the closure as the product. Ask what the cap must do across dozens of fills: seal, resist your formula, accept a dispenser nozzle and identify the product. The pilot’s reported success rests on leak-proof tops and fixed orientation, not on the bottle shape.
- Procurement: ask suppliers for the basis of any reduction figure: baseline pack, reuse count, and whether reusable-bottle mass is amortised. Ask your supplier for a quote on dispenser hardware separately from consumables. For your own comparison, Free tool: the pack cost calculator works from your own prices per 1,000 packs.
- Design and brand: a professional channel can adopt bulk refill faster than retail, because a facilities team controls who fills what. Consumer refill formats (pods, cartridges, pouches) place the dosing step in untrained hands, so print dosing cues on the pack itself.
- Quality teams: a bottle linked to one product by an NFC tag addresses cross-fill risk, a concern Ecourage itself raises. Decide how you would audit returned bottles for residue before refill.
- Anyone quoting 84%: attribute it to the pilot and say it came from a Dutch professional cleaning environment, not household retail.
Sources
- Sustainable Packaging News: 84% less packaging waste, BRAVE’R project reveals the realities of refill at scale
- Packaging Europe: Sustainability news listing (Reuse pilot for professional cleaning products cuts 84% of packaging)
- Searious Business: BRAVE’R refill cleaning system
- Made: Ecourage, the infrastructure for re-use packaging at scale
- FACHPACK: Ecourage exhibitor profile
- Beauty Innovation: Watch this space, a next-gen refill solution is here
- Ecourage: Ecostore partners with Ecourage to launch refill machines in Japan
- Packaging World: SC Johnson, Reckitt Benckiser launch reusable packaging
- Recoup: Refill packaging case studies
- Ellen MacArthur Foundation: A smart refill system for household products, Replenish
- European Cleaning Journal: Cleaning chemicals, the smartest dosing
- Design News: Cleaner and greener, cleaning products, sustainability and packaging
- Packaging Europe: EU Commission reveals prototype label for upcoming eco-design rules
- PPWR EU: Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation detail
Header image: illustration, AI-generated.

