Finding and fixing channel leaks in VFFS heat seals

Quick answer: A channel leak is a thin unsealed path inside a seal that can look and even peel normally. Locate it first (dye or bubble test), then peel-test the same seal and record the failure mode, then work through jaw pressure and cleanliness before you touch the temperature setpoint.

This piece rests mainly on test-lab pages (LSO, Infinita Lab), machine-maker and automation-supplier troubleshooting guides (Qualipak, Soontact, Pac Right, Rovema) and peer-reviewed seal research. Several of those firms sell machines, testing services or leak detectors, so treat their fixes as starting points. Dates and edition numbers below are as of 18 November 2026.

What a channel leak is, and why seal strength alone misses it

A channel is a small unsealed path through the seal area. It is often caused by wrinkles in the film entering the jaws, or by product dust on the sealant surface. In paperboard tray work, researchers found that creases and wrinkles in the sealing surface can act as capillary channels that leak.

That is why two checks are needed. One packaging supplier points out that a strong seal can still leak because of wrinkles, and a weak seal can look intact. Strength tells you about the bond; a leak test tells you whether there’s a path.

A troubleshooting sequence for a leaking seal

Work in this order. Each step narrows the cause before you change a setting.

  1. Describe the leak pattern. Contamination leaks tend to be localised and irregular rather than running evenly along the seal, whereas a leak at the same spot on every bag points at the jaw, a wrinkle or a worn pad.
  2. Locate it. Use dye penetration or a bubble test (see the test table below) so you know where the path is before you cut anything open.
  3. Peel-test the seal and record the failure mode. A clean adhesive peel, a film tear and a delamination each point at a different cause.
  4. Confirm the real sealing conditions. Check jaw-face temperature with a calibrated method, verify pneumatic pressure and inspect the timing of jaw closure. The setpoint on the screen is not the temperature at the film.
  5. Inspect the wear parts. Look at alignment, PTFE tape, serration condition, heaters, thermocouples and signs of contamination. One guide suggests checking jaw alignment with carbon paper.
  6. Move the fix upstream if the cause is product. Contamination usually needs changes upstream of the jaws.
  7. Change one variable, then re-test. One supplier guide suggests incremental temperature steps such as +5 °C; it’s a vendor suggestion, so check it against your film’s data sheet.

Free tool: the printable checklists are a handy place to keep your own jaw-inspection list next to the line.

Causes and fixes by symptom

The table collects what the machine-maker and supplier guides cited in this article report. Treat it as a checklist of candidates, not a diagnosis; your film and jaw design will shift the order.

Symptom Likely cause First fix to try
Fine channels, leak at a repeat position Uneven jaw pressure, which lets air escape through gaps; ageing silicone pressure strip; clogged serrations Replace the strip, clean or replace the jaw faces, check that the jaws close parallel
Random, irregular leaks, dusty seal area Product in the seal; product falling too late or settling time too short Adjust drop timing, check that the fill tube ends above the seal area; some applications use tuck filling
Seal peels open cleanly Temperature too low, pressure too low or dwell too short (per a machine-maker guide) Verify the true jaw temperature; dwell shortens as machine speed rises unless jaw design compensates
Burn marks, brittle seal Temperature too high; excess dwell Reduce temperature in small steps; shorten dwell. Too much pressure can also thin the seal edge.
Wrinkles at the seal Film not lying flat on the collar; film width not matched to the forming tube; tension Reduce film tension to the minimum for stable running and check film-contact surfaces for burrs.
Vertical seal band sticks or wrinkles Temperature or pressure too high; film tracking exposing the sealant layer to the band Check tracking first, then lower temperature or air pressure (Rovema’s notes)
Good bags and leakers mixed Drifting heat control or air supply One guide advises monthly calibration of controllers against an external thermocouple.

What each test tells you

Four ASTM methods cover most of the work on seals. They answer different questions, and the labs that publish most of the detail below serve medical packaging, so check that a method fits your pack and your quality system.

Method Finds Sensitivity Destructive
ASTM F88/F88M (peel) Seal force and failure mode N/A (force per width) Yes
ASTM F1921 (hot tack) Seal strength while still hot N/A (force per width) Yes
ASTM F1929 (dye, porous) and F3039 (dye, non-porous) Channels in seals About 50 µm channel for F1929 Yes (dye in the seal)
ASTM F2096 (bubble) Gross leaks anywhere in the pack About 250 µm Yes

ASTM F88: seal strength and failure mode

F88 measures seal strength at ambient temperature on seals between two flexible materials, or a flexible material and a rigid one such as a lid. It’s reported as average and maximum force per unit seal width, for example N/15 mm or N/25 mm. One lab guide lists F88/F88M-23 as the current edition; check the current text before you write a specification.

The test setup changes the number. The seal can be unsupported (technique A) or held at 90° (B) or 180° (C) to the pull direction, and values from different support techniques cannot be compared directly. Separation speed is set between 200 and 300 mm/min in one summary, and the speed and tail support must be reported. For fin seals, the orientation of the fin tail during the test can change the result significantly.

Read the failure mode, not just the peak. LSO lists adhesive peel, elongation, delamination, material tear, cohesive failure and incomplete seal (channels, seal creep or narrow seals). The standard warns that when other modes occur alongside peel, energy and similar functions must be interpreted with caution.

ASTM F1921: hot tack

Hot tack matters on a VFFS line because the seal is loaded by the falling product before it cools. The method seals specimens at a controlled temperature, pressure and dwell, then separates them while the seal is still hot. Hot tack and final seal strength are different measures, so a cooled seal can pass while the fresh seal fails during filling.

Test conditions vary by lab. One peer-reviewed study used 1.0 s seal time, 0.3 N/mm2 seal pressure and 0.1 s cool time, with a tensile speed of 200 mm/s. In that study one film had a hot tack initiation temperature of 105 °C and another 90 °C, which is why the film’s seal window matters as much as the jaw setting.

Leak tests: F1929, F3039 and F2096

F1929 detects a leak equal to or larger than a channel formed by a 50 µm (0.002 in) wire in edge seals between a transparent film and a porous sheet. F3039 is the dye method for non-porous materials. The Sterilization Packaging Association’s FAQ (last updated 2015) notes that F1929 is significantly more sensitive than F2096.

F2096 covers the whole pack. The package is punctured, air is fed in at a set pressure under water, and a bubble stream marks the leak; it is destructive. Infinita Lab reports detection down to about 250 µm, with an 81 percent probability of detection at that size. For finer leaks, vacuum decay (F2338) or dye penetration is used. A cheap first screen is visual inspection to ASTM F1886, which checks for visible channels, wrinkles or gaps in flexible package seals.

Film choices that widen the margin

Fin seals join sealant to sealant; a lap seal can require one side of the structure to seal to the opposite surface, so a laminate that suits a fin seal may not suit a lap seal.

For product-in-seal problems, the sealant layer matters. A 2023 review in Packaging Technology and Science reports that LLDPE blends reduced hot tack initiation temperatures by 3 to 4 °C against an LDPE reference, and that a plastomer-based seal layer reached 90 °C initiation and leak-tight seals in all contaminated cases evaluated. An earlier study found hot tack tests are predictive of contaminated seal performance, although the sodium ionomer film’s hot tack results were not predictive.

Material change means new settings. A new film may need different jaw temperatures, pressure, cooling time or machine speed.

Why seal initiation numbers don’t travel

Our calculation: two patents define “seal initiation” differently. One defines it as 1 lb/inch seal strength, the other as strength above 4.4 N per 12.7 mm. Convert both to N per 25.4 mm: 1 lbf/in is 4.45 N per 25.4 mm, and 4.4 N × (25.4 / 12.7) is 8.8 N per 25.4 mm. The second threshold is about 2.0 times (8.8 / 4.45) the first, so a “SIT” quoted by one supplier can sit at a different point on the curve from another’s.

Temperature units mix too. A machine-maker guide quotes common poly films sealing around 330 to 350 °F, which is about 166 to 177 °C. Treat it as a typical range, not a film specification.

Common mistakes

  • Raising temperature to fix a pressure or contamination leak, which risks burn-through and brittle seals.
  • Reporting a peel number without the failure mode, tail support, speed and specimen width.
  • Trusting a bubble test for fine channels. F2096 targets gross leaks.
  • Comparing seal strengths across support techniques, or SIT figures across suppliers with different thresholds.
  • Passing cooled seals on final strength and ignoring hot tack.
  • Leaving jaw consumables and thermocouples unchecked while chasing film specifications.

What this means for you

If you run a line, make jaw-face temperature, pneumatic pressure and consumable condition part of the shift check, and inspect those before any setpoint change. For product-in-seal problems, change fill timing before you change the jaws.

If you write specifications, state the F88 technique, speed, specimen width and conditioning, and ask the supplier for hot tack curves with their test conditions. Ask for a quote on any sealant change; don’t assume a drop-in swap.

If you validate packs, pair a strength test with a leak test, and agree the method with your quality team. For pharma or medical packs, method choice and acceptance criteria belong to your regulatory and quality teams and the applicable pharmacopoeia or authority.

Sources

Values are typical figures from the cited sources. Real performance depends on the grade, the test method and the conditions. Check the supplier's data sheet and test your own structure.

Header image: illustration, AI-generated.