Tetra Recart vs the steel can for tuna: what each is made of

Quick answer: Tetra Recart is a six-layer laminate of paperboard, aluminium foil and polypropylene that’s sterilised in a retort like a can. It suits brands selling flaked, shredded or chunk tuna that want a rectangular pack and a lower claimed footprint, and can accept a single-supplier filling system. The steel can keeps the edge where established metal recycling and an existing seamer line matter more.

This piece rests mainly on statements from Tetra Pak and its partner Jealsa, plus trade coverage of them. The one independent-looking review cited below was published by metal-packaging industry bodies, so it has its own interest. Independent test data on the carton versus the can was not found in the sources used.

What the carton is made of

Tetra Pak’s technical page describes six layers: four of polypropylene, one of aluminium, and one of paperboard. Packaging World, reporting on a US pasta-meal launch by Pacific Foods, gave the order from the inside as polypropylene, aluminum foil, PP, paperboard, PP, and lacquer. The two lists agree once the outer lacquer is counted with the polypropylene.

The polypropylene matters because it survives the retort. Packaging Digest reported that the laminate can be retorted at conventional retort temperatures (up to 262 deg F for up to two hr). That’s about 128 °C, using (262 − 32) × 5 ÷ 9. The foil is the gas barrier. A Tetra Laval patent on retortable laminates (US 2007/0298196) describes acidic food components creeping through the inner coating and weakening the bond to the foil, and proposes a polar barrier layer between them. The public sources don’t say whether the commercial pack uses it.

Paperboard share is the figure that drifts. The US launch coverage said 65 percent paperboard. An older Tetra Pak page citing a 2017 life cycle assessment said at least 69%, and the current page says up to 71%.

Paperboard share of Tetra Recart, as stated over time. Paperboard share stated: US launch coverage (about 65) 65, Older Tetra Pak page, 2017 LCA (at least 69) 69, Current Tetra Pak page (up to 71) 71 (percent)
Paperboard share of Tetra Recart, as stated over time
Source: Packaging Digest; Tetra Pak web pages (Croatia and global); values are stated floors or ceilings, not measurements

The format itself dates from 2003. A food-science reference describes it as a blank-fed, retortable, square-shaped paperboard carton sold as a can replacement and a rival to the retort pouch. Packaging Digest noted that Tetra Pak supplies both the form/fill machine and the cartons, which shapes the buying decision later in this piece.

Why tuna, and who is saying what

Tetra Pak and the Spanish seafood group Jealsa announced what Tetra Pak calls the industry’s first carton for shelf-stable tuna. The pitch leans on a market study Tetra Pak commissioned from Meticulous Research, which New Food Magazine reports expects the global shelf-stable tuna market to reach 12.4 billion units by 2030. The same Tetra Pak study found more than 80 percent of consumers surveyed would buy tuna packaged in Tetra Recart, while 58 percent said they preferred it to existing options. That’s a company-commissioned survey, not shelf data.

The pitch has now reached the Philippines. The Inquirer reported this month that Tetra Pak wants local tuna brands to consider the carton, and that Tetra Pak says it wants producers to consider Tetra Recart as another packaging option, rather than replace their existing lines outright. Tetra Pak also says the carton can take ready meals, per the same article.

Carton, can and pouch side by side

The table compares the three retortable formats named in the sources. Cells summarise what the cited outlets say; they’re not specifications.

Format Construction Heat path in the retort End of life Main trade-off
Tetra Recart carton Paperboard, aluminium foil and four polypropylene layers, flexo printed Thin rectangular profile; needs a dedicated retort rack Carton stream; Tetra Pak and the metal bodies disagree on how to count it Tetra Pak machine and carton supply; 200 ml is the smallest listed size
Steel can Rigid metal body with a crimped lid Thicker and heavier, so slower to reach sterile temperature in the core Steel packaging recycled at 84% in the EU in 2024, per its industry body Heavy and bulky to ship empty
Retort pouch Polyester, aluminium foil and polypropylene laminate Flat, so faster than a can Multilayer; recycling often limited, per one pouch supplier Less stacking strength than a can

The pouch construction comes from the US Department of Agriculture’s FSIS, which states the pouch is made of layered polyester, aluminum foil, and polypropylene and is retorted at 240 to 250 degrees F, roughly 116 to 121 °C. The stacking point comes from an old retort-pouch patent, which says a tin can inherently has greater stacking strength than a pouch.

Heat, space and freight

A flat pack heats faster than a round one. FSIS says a pouch is flat, it takes much less time than a metal can to reach commercial sterilisation. Pacific Foods’ brand manager made a similar argument for the carton, saying Recart cartons have a thin profile and a very high ratio of surface area to volume. Process times still have to be set per product, container type and size, as the food-science reference notes for pouches.

Tetra Pak’s Recart campaign page claims the rectangular pack takes up 30% less space than cans and glass jars. It lists sizes of 200ml, 340ml, 390ml, 440ml, 500ml (the page text says four sizes, then names five). Filling runs on two platforms at up to 6,000 packs per hour, or even as many as 24,000 packs per hour, and the page says 80 brands in more than 40 countries use the format.

On empty-pack freight, Packaging Digest reported that a pallet holds 35,000 carton blanks, so one truckload corresponds to roughly 15 trucks of empty cans or glass jars. Our calculation: 1 truck ÷ 15 trucks = 0.067, so about 7% of the inbound truck movements for empty packaging, on that claim. The figure comes from early commercial reporting on the format. Re-check it against your own can sizes and wall weights.

Footprint and recycling claims

Tetra Pak says Recart’s lifetime emissions are 85% lower than those of steel cans and 83% lower than those of glass jars, citing its own 2020 comparative life cycle assessment of the European market. The older Tetra Pak page gave a lower figure, 81% lower than those of steel cans and glass jars, from a 2017 study. The gap shows how much the number moves with the study year and assumptions.

Metal Packaging Europe and Steel for Packaging Europe published an independent assessment of comparative LCA studies, commissioned by the two metal bodies. In the extract available, it argues that the “recyclable” claim for Tetra Recart alone may mislead, and notes that recycled carton fibre isn’t used to make Tetra Recart again but goes into other carton products. Read it as the metal side’s rebuttal, and read Tetra Pak’s LCA as the carton side’s case.

For the can, Canmaking News reports that Steel for Packaging Europe gave a record EU steel packaging recycling rate of 84% for 2024, calculated at the point material enters recycling. I didn’t find a comparable carton figure in these sources, so there’s no like-for-like recycling number here. The EU’s PPWR sets recyclability and labelling rules that will bear on both formats; check the current text at ppwreu.org before putting a recyclability claim on pack.

What this means for you

  • R&D: ask Tetra Pak for retort validation data on your product, particle size and carton size, and for the rack specification. A heat path that works for brine-packed chunks won’t carry over to a thick sauce.
  • Procurement: the carton and its filler come from one supplier, so compare total delivered cost, capital, spare-part terms and exit options, not just carton price. Ask for a quote; Free tool: the pack cost calculator turns your own quoted prices into cost per 1,000 packs.
  • Design: the pack is flexo printed and opaque, so there’s no product window. Check that 200 ml, the smallest size on Tetra Pak’s page, fits your portion sizes.
  • Claims: treat the 85% and 83% figures as Tetra Pak’s, tied to a 2020 European study. Commission or request a study that matches your markets before reusing them.
  • Layer stack: Free tool: the laminate estimator gives an indicative layer-stack weight and barrier if you want to sketch alternatives against the carton’s structure.

Sources

Header image: illustration, AI-generated.