Heat seal failures on VFFS lines: causes, tests and fixes

Quick answer: Most seal failures on a form-fill-seal line come back to four variables: the temperature the jaw actually reaches, dwell time, jaw pressure and parallelism, and anything trapped in the seal. Confirm the fault with a peel test (ASTM F88) plus a burst or leak test, because each answers a different question. Some faults that look like seal failures, such as tunnelling and delamination, start at the laminator.

This sheet is for packaging engineers, quality teams and procurement people who get the call when a pouch leaks. It covers what to check first, how to read the standard tests, and where the published guidance is vendor opinion rather than a rule. Most of the troubleshooting numbers below come from machine and film suppliers’ own guides, so treat them as starting points for your film and your jaws, not specifications.

Start here: a five-step check before you touch a setting

Changing three parameters at once is the fastest way to lose the cause. Work through the list in order and change one thing per trial.

  1. Measure the jaw, not the display. One VFFS troubleshooting guide from a machine supplier recommends calibrating temperature controllers monthly against an external thermocouple, because controllers drift over time.
  2. Look at the jaw faces. Daily checks for burnt-on plastic or product build-up are advised, and a brass tool rather than steel avoids damaging the coating. Clogged serrations also reduce the grip and the pressure applied to the seal area.
  3. Check parallelism. Suppliers describe running the jaws on carbon paper or plain paper; an even impression across the whole seal width is the pass, and a patchy one means the faces aren’t meeting squarely.
  4. Check where the product stops. If product, dust or fat reaches the seal area, no temperature setting will fix it (see the contamination section).
  5. Only then adjust. One published first-adjustment table suggests moving temperature by 5 to 10 C, or dwell by 0.1 to 0.2 seconds, depending on whether the seal is weak or burnt.

The seal window: temperature, dwell and pressure

A heat seal is a trade between three variables. A generic supplier guide gives typical VFFS ranges of 150 to 250 C, 1 to 5 bar and 0.1 to 1 second, which is wide enough to be useless for any one film. Your film supplier’s seal window for your exact sealant layer is the number to use.

Pressure is the one people misread. One supplier explains that pressure may be quoted as cylinder pressure, regulator pressure or actual line force, and these aren’t interchangeable. Too little leaves channels and wrinkles; too much can squeeze molten sealant out of the joint, narrow the effective seal and mark the film. The same source says a flat, parallel jaw with even pressure distribution usually matters more than turning up the regulator.

Why the seal curve and the hot tack curve both matter

A heat seal curve plots seal strength against sealing temperature. The start of the rise is the heat seal initiation temperature (HSIT), and the figure only has meaning with its definition attached. Published examples define it as 1 lb/inch at 0.27 N/mm2, 0.25 s dwell and 254 mm/min peel in one resin patent, 200 g/25 mm in a BOPLA film patent, and 2 lb in a polyethylene patent. Three definitions, three different numbers for what looks like the same property.

On a vertical line the bag is filled while the end seal is still warm, so hot tack (ASTM F1921) is the relevant property. That method measures the force needed to separate a seal before it has fully cooled. A hot tack curve typically passes through a maximum and then falls as temperature rises, because melt strength drops, so running hotter isn’t a safe way to buy speed.

One resin patent argues that a lower initiation temperature means a broader heat seal window, allowing more consistent sealing on automatic lines and higher speeds. That’s a supplier claim about its own material; ask for the curves on your actual film.

Troubleshooting table: symptom, cause, first action

The table merges guidance from several machine and film suppliers. Where they agree it’s reliable as a first pass; where a single vendor gives a number, that number is theirs.

Symptom Likely cause First action
Seal opens cleanly at low force Temperature or dwell too low Raise temperature 5-10 C or dwell 0.1-0.2 s; verify with a calibrated probe (Kinsun)
Burn marks, brittle seal edge Temperature or dwell too high Reduce temperature 5-10 C; inspect jaw alignment
Wrinkles across the seal Uneven pressure, poor web tension, misaligned jaws Check parallelism and tracking; for fin-seal wrinkles, check forming tube size against film width and collar alignment (Bagpackingmachine)
Random leaks near product Product or dust in the seal; low pressure Fix fill timing and product control before touching heat
Strength drifts across a shift Sensor drift, heater cycling, film variation Log actual jaw temperature; compare reels
Seal too strong to peel as designed Overheating, long dwell or high pressure Move back toward the middle of the peelable window
Seal passes, layers inside the film separate Low laminate bond: coat weight, corona, cure Run a laminate bond test and trace the reel
Tunnels appear hours or days after lamination Web tension mismatch, moisture, cure Review unwind tension and rewind settings

Contamination and channel leaks

Channel leaks are narrow open paths through an otherwise sealed area. Two causes dominate in the published guides: uneven pressure, which one supplier says gives channel leakers where air escapes through gaps in the seal, and product caught between the sealant layers.

For contamination, one machine builder calls product in the seal area the number one cause of leakers. Its suggestions are timing-based: stop product flow about 0.5 seconds before the jaws close, then tune to the product’s flow. It also recommends air knives above the seal area, especially for powders, and confirming that the fill tube ends above the seal. The 0.5 s figure is one vendor’s starting point, not a standard.

The film matters too. Resin suppliers describe a “caulkability” test that evaluates how well a sealant layer seals through contamination, using an inflation system with restraint plates. If your product is dusty, oily or particulate, ask the film supplier for seal-through-contamination data rather than relying on a clean-film seal curve.

Lamination faults that show up as pack failures

A laminated pouch can fail with the seal intact. One converter guide lists the symptom as good seal integrity while the laminate layers separate, and warns that weak bonds often only show up at curing, slitting, pouch making, transport or customer use.

Delamination

Published cause lists are consistent. A converter guide names poor surface treatment on PET, BOPP or nylon, slip or antiblock additives migrating to the surface, and an adhesive that can’t resist the contents. On the adhesive side it lists incorrect mix ratio, insufficient cure, and low or uneven coat weight. A coating supplier adds insufficient nip temperature or impression, contaminated substrate and insufficient drying.

Solventless laminates need patience before judging. One laminator supplier says the main bond develops through cross-linking over 48 to 72 hours in the curing room, so a fresh-reel peel value is not the final one.

Tunnelling

Tunnelling is delamination in bands that leaves a tunnel-like appearance. Machine builder Crest describes it as a tension mismatch frozen into the product: one web was laminated under higher tension, and after winding the stretched web relaxes and releases. Its stated fix is independent, accurate tension control on every unwind.

An adhesive supplier lists wider contributors: moisture differences between substrates, insufficient cure, web tension imbalance, rewind taper settings and excessive coating weight. For aluminium foil structures in solventless lamination, one equipment supplier quotes a window of 1.8 to 2.3 g/m2, with higher weights causing hydrodynamic instability and tunnelling. That window is one vendor’s figure for its own process; get yours from your adhesive supplier. The unit converter helps if the data sheet is in lb/ream.

Curl

I found no verified numerical limits for laminate curl. Crest lists curl among defects that trace back to nip pressure, web tension, roller alignment or winding settings, so start the investigation at the laminator and the rewind rather than in the filler.

Which test answers which question

The standards overlap in name but not in what they tell you. The F1140 text itself says its result does not necessarily correlate with seal strength measured by F88.

Method Answers Key conditions or limits
ASTM F88 How much force separates one seal, and how it fails Strip cut through the seal; grip rate 200-300 mm/min; technique A, B or C
ASTM F1921 Strength of a seal before it cools Hot tack curve vs temperature; seal bar dwell and delay time must be reported
ASTM F2054 Where the seal perimeter is weakest Package between restraining plates, pressurised with air
ASTM F1140 Whether the whole package holds a pressure Unrestrained burst or creep; finds the single weakest point
ASTM F2338 Whether a leak path exists Vacuum decay; non-destructive; porous surfaces must be masked
ASTM F1929 Visible dye through channels Probabilistic; operator-read

On the burst side, a lab note explains that restraining plates improve repeatability on lidded trays and larger pouches, which can peel at the seams if not restrained. On the leak side, ASTM released F2338-24 as a revision of the vacuum decay method; a test-equipment supplier says it now covers non-porous flexible packaging and cites defects as small as 5 µm. A testing lab quotes a more cautious 10 to 50 µm depending on package size and conditions, and around 50 µm for dye penetration. Sensitivity depends on the pack, so treat these as ranges.

The older F2338 text notes the method suits 100 percent on-line testing or statistical sampling. If you work with pharmaceutical packs, the method, limits and sample plans are decided with your regulatory and quality teams and the applicable pharmacopoeia or authority; this article doesn’t cover that.

Running an F88 peel test so the numbers mean something

F88 is the test most people quote and the one most often reported without its conditions. A test-equipment supplier summarises the method as measuring the tensile strength of the seal at ambient temperature, as the maximum force needed to separate the two layers under particular conditions.

  1. Condition the samples and say how. Published lab practices vary: one patent quotes 23 C ±2 and 50% ±2 RH with 2 hours of conditioning; another quotes a minimum of 40 hours at 23 C ±2 and 50% ±10 RH. Pick one and state it.
  2. Cut to a defined width. The current version allows cutter widths of 25 mm, 15 mm or 25.4 mm, with a recommended tolerance of ±0.5 percent.
  3. Position the seal. Per a testing-equipment guide, the seal line sits perpendicular to the pull and roughly equidistant between the grips.
  4. Set the grip separation rate. 200 to 300 mm/min is the standard range. Some company methods use 500 mm/min on 15 mm strips, which is a variant, so don’t compare those numbers directly.
  5. Choose and record the support technique. Technique A leaves the seal unsupported; B holds it at 90 degrees to the pull and C at 180 degrees. Thin films or stiff laminates sometimes need B or C for more controlled peel geometry.
  6. Report peak force, width, direction and failure mode. The report should include machine direction relative to the pull, the maximum force, and the way the seal failed. Average force can matter when opening behaviour is the question.
  7. Use enough replicates. A patent example uses at least three; your quality plan should set the real sample size.

Failure mode is where the diagnosis lives. A film that tears outside the seal says the seal is stronger than the web; a clean peel says the seal sits below it; a split inside the laminate sends you to the bond, not the jaws.

Common mistakes

  • Trusting the controller readout. Drift and heater cycling are listed as causes of seal strength changing across a shift, so measure at the jaw.
  • Quoting N/15 mm with nothing else. Width, rate, technique and conditioning change the number. For N/m, multiply N/15 mm by 66.7.
  • Using burst pressure as a stand-in for peel strength. The F1140 text says they don’t necessarily correlate.
  • Raising pressure to cure everything. Past a point it thins the seal by squeezing out sealant.
  • Judging a laminate too early. Tunnels can appear hours or days later, and solventless bonds keep building for 48 to 72 hours.
  • Chasing the sealer when the laminate is at fault. If layers split inside the film while the seal holds, check coat weight, corona level and cure on the reel.

What this means for you

Build a one-page seal record for each film and pack: actual jaw temperature, dwell, pressure, F88 result with width, rate and technique, and the failure mode. Print the checklists from the downloads page if you want a starting template.

Ask film suppliers for a heat seal curve and a hot tack curve on the exact grade, with the test conditions and the HSIT definition printed on them. Ask separately for seal-through-contamination data if the product is dusty or oily.

Use F88 for process settings, a burst or leak method for pack integrity, and a laminate bond test for converter incoming checks. Whichever acceptance limits you set, base them on your product, shelf life and distribution route, and agree them with your quality team. If a regulation touches your pack, check the current text via ppwreu.org.

Sources

Values are typical figures from the cited sources. Real performance depends on the grade, the test method and the conditions. Check the supplier's data sheet and test your own structure.