Quick answer: A passive shipper is an insulated box plus a refrigerant, and the pairing matters more than either part. Insulation sets how fast heat leaks in, the refrigerant sets how much heat it can soak up at the right temperature, and a qualification run under a defined profile tells you whether the combination holds. This is an education piece: material and format choices for any real product are decided with your regulatory and quality teams and the applicable pharmacopoeia or authority.
What a passive shipper actually does
Cold chain packaging systems are usually grouped by how they hold temperature. Passive systems rely on phase change materials, active systems use battery-powered refrigeration under thermostat control, and hybrids combine both. The same source notes that most systems in use are passive.
Patent literature describes the split in similar terms. Active shippers hold temperature with a battery or mains-powered device, and they tend to be expensive and bulky. Passive shippers keep temperature without any battery or electrical support.
Think of a passive shipper as a heat budget. Heat arrives through the walls at a rate set by the insulation, the wall thickness, the surface area and the gap between outside and inside temperature. The refrigerant absorbs that heat until it runs out. When it does, the payload starts to drift.
That framing explains most design trade-offs. Better insulation means less refrigerant for the same hold time, or longer hold time for the same refrigerant. A bigger payload cavity means more wall area and more heat to absorb. A hot lane needs more budget than a mild one.
Passive shippers also have two failure directions. A 2 to 8 °C label has a floor as well as a ceiling, which is why refrigerant choice gets as much attention as insulation.
Insulation: EPS, PUR and vacuum insulated panels
Three insulation families cover most parcel-scale pharma shippers. EPS shippers use expanded polystyrene foam and may add corrugated outer boxes, vacuum panels, phase change materials, gel bricks or dry ice. Other expanded foams such as EPP and EPE are used too.
PUR shippers are made by pouring a liquid mix of isocyanate, polyol, catalysts and blowing agent into a corrugated box and letting it cure and foam. That gives a one-piece foam wall bonded to the carton.
VIPs work differently. A vacuum insulated panel has a porous core of fused silica, aerogel or glass fibre, sealed under vacuum inside a metallised or plain plastic film envelope. Removing the air removes most of the conduction path. The film is also the weak point, because a puncture lets air back in.
Published conductivity figures vary by grade and source, so treat the chart below as typical ranges, not specifications. The numbers come from one VIP supplier’s technical blog, which is a commercial source. Other suppliers give similar orders of magnitude: one guide puts rigid PU at about 0.025, EPS at 0.035 and VIPs under 0.008 W/(m K).

The practical consequence is wall thickness. One patent description says EPS or polyurethane would need to be roughly seven or eight times thicker than a VIP to match it. A supplier calculation under ASTM C680 reaches a similar picture: at a 50 mm wall, PU at 0.023 W/(m K) gives about 21.7 W/m2 of heat gain, against about 4.15 W/m2 for a VIP at 0.0042 W/(m K). That is a vendor’s own comparison of its product.
VIPs are not a free upgrade. One guide lists them as fragile, to be used inside a rigid shell, with specialist recovery at end of life. Patent text on VIP shippers also points to edge leaks, meaning air gaps that open at the joints when five panels are taped or strapped into a box.
| Insulation | Typical conductivity, W/(m K) | Where it tends to fit | Trade-offs |
|---|---|---|---|
| EPS | About 0.030 to 0.040 | Short single-use lanes | Thick walls for longer holds; cracks and surface damage; limited reuse |
| PUR foam | About 0.020 to 0.030 | Mid-duration shippers, some reusable designs | Moderate cost and complexity; foam bonded to carton, so harder to separate |
| VIP (inside a rigid shell) | About 0.002 to 0.008 | Long holds, tight volume or weight limits | Puncture sensitivity; edge leaks at joints; higher unit cost; specialist recovery |
Source for the conductivity column: Fujian Super Tech blog; the qualitative columns draw on the same page and the patent and guide sources listed below. For cost, ask your supplier for a quote.
Refrigerants: gel, PCM and dry ice
The refrigerant is chosen by the temperature band the product label asks for. Water-based gel packs are the familiar choice for chilled lanes, but they carry a known weakness. Refrigerated-water designs for 2 to 8 °C suffer from freeze sensitivity, and swapping in a 2 to 8 °C PCM is reported to improve performance with little disruption.
PCMs are formulated to melt near a chosen temperature, so they hold a plateau through most of the melt. One guide pairs gel packs at 0 °C and phase-change packs at 5 °C for the 2 to 8 °C band. Another lists a PCM tuned to about 22 °C for the 15 to 25 °C controlled room temperature band.
Dry ice is the usual route to deep frozen. It sublimates at −78.5 °C at normal atmospheric pressure. That changes the packaging design, because the gas has to go somewhere. One logistics guide states that a gas-tight package is not permitted for air freight.
Colder is not automatically safer. A product labelled for −20 °C should not sit against a −78.5 °C surface for days, and going below the specified temperature also counts as an excursion. Shippers using dry ice often separate it from the payload; a long-standing refrigerant patent describes a separator and gel pack to keep dry ice from touching the goods.
Dry ice also brings dangerous goods paperwork. It ships as UN 1845, Class 9, while PCM falls outside that category. The air rules sit in IATA Dangerous Goods Regulations (packing instruction 954), and they change, so check the current text with your carrier and dangerous goods adviser. For EU packaging law that could touch shipper design, such as PPWR, see ppwreu.org and check the current text.
| Refrigerant | Working temperature, °C | Typical band | Watch-outs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conditioned gel pack | Around 0 (melt of water) | 2 to 8 °C, with conditioning | Freeze risk at the payload; coolant mass; condensation and leakage |
| PCM pack, 5 °C grade | About 5 | 2 to 8 °C | Wrong melt point; poor conditioning; supply specification |
| PCM pack, 22 °C grade | About 22 | 15 to 25 °C | Needs conditioning to the right start temperature |
| Dry ice | −78.5 | Deep frozen | CO2 venting; Class 9 marking; overcooling a −20 °C product; weight loss in transit |
Sources: Balaji Internationals, Ecko Ice Products and Coolpack, all supplier or logistics guides. Melt points on real products vary by formulation.
How shippers are tested: ISTA 7E, Standard 20 and USP 1079
Qualification gives a shipper its evidence. Two ISTA documents come up most often. ISTA 7E is designed to evaluate the effect of external temperature exposure on individually packaged products moving through a parcel delivery system. It includes heat and cold profiles built from data gathered in real transport.
One lab-services page describes the origin of the data: round-trip shipments over 82 different lanes with a parcel carrier. ISTA developed the 7E profiles with the Pharmaceutical Cold Chain Interest Group after surveying US parcel temperature ranges.
Standard 20 is the process wrapper. It sets minimum requirements for qualifying insulated shipping containers, including the 7E thermal profiles. The requirements include trained thermal professionals, documented lab protocols and an on-site audit of the lab by a certified auditor.
Two limits are worth knowing. Standard 20 does not assess protection from shock, vibration or compression, and the 7E profiles are not meant to represent worst-case parcel exposure. A shipper that passes a 7E profile has passed that profile. Lanes with hotter summers, longer customs holds or a different carrier may need lane-specific data.
ISTA says its documents are recommended to support an FDA-regulated organisation’s compliance activities on insulated container thermal performance, in line with CDER process validation guidance. That is ISTA’s positioning. Whether a given qualification package satisfies a given authority is a call for your quality and regulatory teams.
USP chapter <1079> sits above the test method. It gives guidance on storage, distribution and shipping of pharmacopeial preparations. On packaging, it says qualification studies should reflect actual load configurations and environmental conditions, and that both active and passive thermal systems should be tested. A supplier write-up of the revised chapter says it now sets out responsibilities for every partner from manufacturer to last-mile pharmacy.
A related USP notice on mean kinetic temperature (<1079.2>) describes MKT as a way of expressing the cumulative thermal stress a product has experienced. How, or whether, it applies to a transit excursion for a particular product is a stability and quality decision. Read the current chapter text for the detail.
Reading a hold-time claim
Hold-time numbers on data sheets are easy to compare and hard to compare fairly. They depend on the temperature band, the profile, the payload volume, how the refrigerant was conditioned and how full the box was.
Supplier figures show the spread. One cold chain guide says qualified passive shippers using VIPs and engineered PCMs commonly hold 2 to 8 °C for 96 to 120 hours under ISTA 7E ambient profiles. Another vendor reports VIP shippers with an R-value around 36 holding frozen temperatures for more than seven days with a suitable PCM. Both are supplier statements, not independent data.
Pack size matters as much as the headline. One catalogue lists a 2 to 8 °C system for 48 hours with a 2.1 litre payload space and a system weight of 7.7 lb (about 3.5 kg), and a 96-hour system with 5.2 litres of payload space at 12 lb (about 5.4 kg). Longer hold, more mass, more cube per litre of payload.
A patent applicant’s own case study gives a flavour of the VIP argument. For a summer ambient profile aiming to stay below −20 °C for at least 96 hours, the VIP sandwich shipper stayed below −20 °C 12 hours longer than a PUR shipper, and was 20 percent smaller in volume and 18 percent lower in weight. That is one applicant’s example, run on its own designs.
Shipper cube also feeds into pallet and truck fill, which the pallet load calculator can estimate from your own carton dimensions.
Sustainability and handling trade-offs
Insulation is a sustainability problem as well as a thermal one. A 2025 systematic review reports that petrochemical-based insulation produces 5.6 to 6.2 kg CO2 equivalent per kg of insulation. It surveys biopolymers, cellulose, mycelium and bio-PCMs as emerging alternatives. Treat those as early-stage options until a supplier can show qualification data for your profile.
Reuse changes the maths. A reusable VIP shipper has a higher per-trip handling load (return logistics, cleaning, panel inspection) but spreads material impact over many trips. A single-use EPS box has the opposite profile. Neither is better in the abstract; it depends on the lane, the return rate and the qualification of each cycle.
Questions to ask suppliers and your regulatory and quality teams
Material choice and compliance are decided with your regulatory and quality teams and the applicable pharmacopoeia or authority. This list is a starting point for those conversations, not a verdict on any product.
For the shipper supplier
- Which temperature profile, from which standard and version, was the hold time measured against?
- What payload volume, pack-out and refrigerant conditioning were used in the run?
- Were the test runs done in a lab with a stated certification, and can you see the report?
- For VIPs: how are panels protected, and how do you inspect for vacuum loss between uses?
- For dry ice: what venting design is used, and what does the dangerous goods documentation require?
- What is the end-of-life route for the foam, panel and refrigerant?
For your regulatory and quality teams
- What temperature range and excursion allowance does the product’s own stability data support?
- Does the lane need data beyond the standard profile, such as hotter summers or longer dwell?
- Who owns requalification when the pack-out, supplier or lane changes?
- How will temperature be monitored in transit, and what happens to a shipment after an alarm?
What this means for you
If you’re an engineer comparing shippers, start with the temperature band and the lane, then the insulation. For short holds and low unit cost, foam is the starting point. When volume or weight limits bite or the hold stretches past a few days, VIPs are the family suppliers point to, with handling risk attached.
If you’re in procurement, ask for the profile, payload and conditioning behind every hold-time claim before you compare prices. Two shippers with the same headline hours can differ by a factor of two in cube once the test conditions are lined up.
If you’re in quality, read USP <1079> and your authority’s distribution guidance as the frame, and treat ISTA 7E as one input. Keep a record of what the qualification covered and what it left out, such as vibration or lane-specific heat.
For a printable starting point, see the checklists on the downloads page, and the material properties table for typical values across packaging materials.
Sources
- USPTO: Method of making a thermally insulated shipper (patent 10329074)
- USPTO: Thermally insulated VIP sandwich shipper and method of making same (patent 9272475)
- USPTO: Passive temperature control carton (patent 12384580)
- USPTO: Refrigerant and method for shipping perishable materials (patent 4377075)
- ResearchGate: Episode II, Efficient Cold Chain Transport using Phase Change Materials
- ResearchGate: Toward Sustainable Cold Chain Packaging, a systematic review
- Fujian Super Tech: Vacuum insulation panel vs traditional insulation
- ISTA: Process standards
- Accuris: ISTA 7E
- Pro-Pack Testing Laboratory: ISTA Series 7 test information
- TempAid: ISTA thermal testing standards for cold chain packaging
- USP: General Chapter 1079 risks and mitigation strategies
- Helmer: USP Chapter 1079 outlines good drug storage and shipping practices
- Sensitech: USP 1079 changes you need to know
- USP-NF: 1079.2 Mean kinetic temperature notice
- Packaura: Cold chain packaging solutions for pharmaceutical shipping
- Cryophase: Pharma cold chain packaging guide, 2 to 8 °C vs frozen
- Intelsius: PharmaTherm 2-8C high performance
- Wedge Insulation: Insulated box
- Balaji Internationals: Cold-chain packaging, insulation, coolant and hold-time maths
- Ecko Ice Products: Passive packaging for cold-chain shipping
- Coolpack: Refrigerated pharmaceutical transport, dry ice or PCM
- PPWR EU: packaging regulation detail
This article is general education about packaging materials, formats and test methods. It is not regulatory, quality or medical advice. For a real product, confirm material choice, testing and compliance with your regulatory and quality teams and the applicable pharmacopoeia and authority.

